[Compared to the others, Wirt is not surprised when it's a normal frog, but he's very surprised for a second at the sheer volume of frogs.
And then, he's not surprised at all, because it's Greg. Of course he's surrounded by a flood of frogs. Of course that's what's happening.]
I-I don't think-
[He was going to say it. He really was. "I don't think that's actually your frog." He had every intention of it, but as he starts to speak the words won't come, due to a weird combination of not wanting to crush Greg's hopes and dreams and feeling like he's not going to be believed anyway. So he forces up an awkward smile instead.]
...I mean, yeah! You sure found him, alright. Good job, Greg! Uh. ...Go you!
[Wirt feels like he's fumbling this and trying way too hard, but maybe it's better than not trying at all?]
Video
And then, he's not surprised at all, because it's Greg. Of course he's surrounded by a flood of frogs. Of course that's what's happening.]
I-I don't think-
[He was going to say it. He really was. "I don't think that's actually your frog." He had every intention of it, but as he starts to speak the words won't come, due to a weird combination of not wanting to crush Greg's hopes and dreams and feeling like he's not going to be believed anyway. So he forces up an awkward smile instead.]
...I mean, yeah! You sure found him, alright. Good job, Greg! Uh. ...Go you!
[Wirt feels like he's fumbling this and trying way too hard, but maybe it's better than not trying at all?]