Of course she's not telling him a lot, she's always not telling him a lot. He's about to counter that when he speaks again, and that gets an eyebrow raise...because, what?

"Either you have suddenly developed a fondness for speaking in third person or you started talking to spiders. Please tell me you haven't started talking to spiders, Nat." Hey, he woke up a few hours ago in some creepy version of a Disney movie, anything is possible at this point.